Monday, December 04, 2006

More hints the Army is broken

If you listened to NPR on 4 December, you're going to know all about this. There was an excellent story about post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Many troops perform honorably in Iraq, but start having problems when they get home. The report was tragic and infuriating. These honorable soldiers are being cut loose for failing to meet behavior standards. As they spiral downward, they sometimes become violent or start using drugs. According to the report, they often attempt to get help from the bureaucratic Army medical system. Troops reporting these symptoms are then shunned and punished for seeking treatment.

As infuriating as the report was, I wasn't surprised. After all, there is a natural tension here. Many of the troops had reenlisted and were starting their career in the Army. Supervisors and leaders need combat ready troops. The Army needs tough troops who can follow orders to kill. The report featured several Sergeant supervisors who admitted to shunning troops with PTSD symptoms. They felt many of the other troops had seen the same things, and that these troops were faking it to avoid repeat tours of Iraq. Supervisor felt the troops need to "buck up." Must be Army lingo.

The reporter tried to imply the Army was systematically drumming out these young troops to avoid paying expensive medical disability. I'm not into conspiracy. This is just the culture of the army. The Army uniformly treats its people like shit. It is the Army way. I've seen it first hand. The Army treated me like shit during my tour with them. So this is just the culture. Buck up. The Army supervisor interviewed made a good point. He said (roughly), "Hey, I've got put my life in these guy's hands. I have to have faith in them. It's hard to have faith in someone snorting coke or smoking dope." Fair enough.

Except, these were normal good troops before they completed their tour in Iraq. The people they interviewed described graphic scenes of carnage I was surprised to hear on the radio. Like the movies, except for real. They served their country, and we all owe them something for that. More specifically, the Army owes them something for that. I get it; they are probably not cut out to serve. When someone shows symptoms of PTSD, they could be discharged for it, but given disability. Sorry, but if the Army breaks it; they get to pay for it.

5 Comments:

At 3:39 PM, Blogger Rambling Jenn said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At 3:41 PM, Blogger Rambling Jenn said...

Very well put and so true.

I've done research of PTSD and it seeps into every aspect of a person's life. Children of those with PTSD can develop what is called "Secondary PTSD" from witnessing their parent going through the disorder and feeling a need to carry some of the burden with them. One un-treated person with PTSD can literally affect generations of people.

Our family knows that first hand...

The Drill Sgt's grandfather suffered PTSD from being an air gunner during WWII. His went un-treated and he finally ended it with a gun and a single shot.

Then the Drill Sgt's dad is now in full swing suffering from PTSD from Vietnam and undoubtable secondary PTSD... he is ATTEMPTING to get help, but has the "Army" mentallity when it comes to mental health. We are trying to get him to understand that PTSD does not mean he is a lesser person.

The Drill Sgt. suffers from "Secondary PTSD" that has been carried over for 3 generations now.

When will it stop?

Not until the government starts talking straight about the affects of war on an individual's mind and taking actions to correct the harm that has been done.

*stepping down off soap box*

Thanks for posting that.

~Rambling Jenn~

 
At 8:01 AM, Blogger nicole said...

I was just listening to NPR last night and there was a story about a police officer who filed for disibility to due severe depression brought on by work environment. Of course, his superiors threw out the claim (and probably told him to 'buck up') but he took it further and the courts determined that his claim was valid.

So how long does this guy get disability?? Depression doesn't just go away. And what sort of precedent does this set for other cases like this in other professions (or in the military)? Basically I'm saying - could I have sued someone this past year because my job was sucking my soul out through my eyeballs?!?

 
At 8:03 AM, Blogger nicole said...

P.S. How do you have over 600 profile views already and are you sure this blog can't be tracked by your superiors?!?

 
At 3:10 PM, Blogger F John said...

I'm using my old profile, but I seriously doubt anyone else would find my Blog based on my profile name. So all those profile views are from the old story.

I enjoyed writing about this article; thanks for your comments.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home